Showing posts with label Workshops & Conferences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Workshops & Conferences. Show all posts

Friday, 10 June 2016

­­­German Habitat Forum, Berlin – Designing Sustainable Solutions for Cities In The Future, 1st June, 2016

Theme- People, Politics and Practice

Sheela Patel spoke at the conference as a representative of communities who live and work informally in cities, and who in her estimation represent a majority of people in the cities. This is a transcript of her speech.

“The city development, as you see it today, excludes with or without purpose the challenges that poor people who live in cities either recently or over the last eight decades have been facing, they remain invisible, and their participation I believe is a very important ingredient in discussions about People, Politics and Practice.

If we don’t start exploring solutions that will make us feel good 50 years from now, we will never begin; because in today’s cities there is inequality, there are huge differences in incomes, in opportunities that have political and many other reasons for not being explored but which will only exaggerate in the future, but we don’t want to wait any more to solve those problems because we can’t solve those problems if we don’t solve them today.

This is a decade of aggregators and organizations like ours, Shack Dwellers International, ACHR; we are all aggregators of urban informality, of men and women living and working in very difficult conditions to reach out to the other players in the city, to find scalable citywide solutions that both picks from what’s outside and take the unique characteristics of the city that is there. So it requires a new disruptive partnership strategy in order for this transformation to occur. Business as usual is not going to work, so do we have the courage, do we have the guts and do we have the capacity to explore these unusual and disruptive solutions?.       
         
In the end a lot of what happens in cities is around land. The politics of who owns land, what its used for, what mechanisms produce inclusion or exclusion forms the basis of how cities evolve and grow and whether they have a chance for sustainable equitable options or not. Politics is at the centre of this, there’s no shortage of technical solutions. Do we have the courage to do that, do we have the capacity to explore new solutions? Because in the end, the sustainability that we are challenged with today (which we start with the meetings we will have for Habitat III, that we’ve come with all our challenges of climate) of our sustainable growth will happen in the geography of cities which will have to deal with a multiplication of challenges and we are far away from that. We should be extremely dissatisfied with what is happening because we don’t have the courage to explore unusual relationships and partnerships.

As the representatives of the networks of the urban poor, we want to explore possible relationships and partnerships, new ways of doing business with whoever has the courage to come and work with us. We are looking for ways by which we transform the future that we prepare for the youth of tomorrow into one which is safe, which turns that into the advantage rather than the violence that we predict that will take place if their aspirations and expectations are not fulfilled by our generation. If we have the courage to explore change, we explore new ways of doing business and of sharing and supporting each other through this process; I think we can see a glimmer of success.”

Wednesday, 10 July 2013

RESTRUCTURING FEDERATIONS IN THE SOUTH July 2013

A three day meeting was held in Bangalore in which 14 cities participated from Tamil Nadu, Pondicherry and Andhra Pradesh.The meeting started with leaders introducing their cities and the work that’s being done in their respective cities. Thomas, federation leader from Bangalore explained the concept and function of NSDF, SPARC, and Mahila Milan to the new emerging cities interested in starting federations.

During the three day meeting the discussions were around:
  1. How each city would report their plans for the next six months.
  2. Challenges faced at the city and settlement level. 
  3. Savings, sanitation, and housing issues were discussed.

 The community toilets give family passes to its older member while the new families have to pay Rs 2 per use - the federation wants to extend the family passes to the new families also.

Field Visit:
Leaders visited settlements where housing and sanitation projects were being implemented to understand how this could be replicated in their own cities.
Committee formation:
  • A state supervising committee was formed.
  • City wise observation committee was formed.
  • Action plan for the next six months prepared.
  • As a result of this exchange and meeting, the Andhra Pradesh federation has been restructured and a district level committee has been formed in four districts.
Contracts:
  • 8,000 families in Bangalore will conduct Basic Socio Economic Survey (BSES).
  • In Mysore, the Karnataka Slum Board to conduct in the first phase Total Station Survey (TSS) and in the second phase, to conduct BSES
Follow up planned:
  • Routine reporting on a quarterly basis on plans made.
  • More emphasis on completing slum profiles.
  • Discussions with municipalities essential.

Saturday, 1 September 2012

JOCKIN REPORTS ON SOME OF HIS ENGAGEMENTS, SEPTEMBER 2012

A Large team from SDI attended the World Urban Forum in Naples in the First week of September. The delegation from india was Celine D’Cruz, (SPARC/SDI) A Jockin, John Samuel, (NSDF) Parveen and Savita ( Mahila Milan ) . There were leaders from several other countries from Asia and Africa in the delegation.
SDI had many events which were at their exhibition center, several networking sessions in which they showcased the work of SDI and its affiliates, and many SDI representatives participated in the events of UNHABITAT in the official program as well as networking programs of other organizations. Over the next few weeks as different members report their presentations, views and activities these will trickle into the blogs.

Jockin at the Panel of “What needs to Change”?
In one of the main Dialogues of the UNHABITAT the question asked to all the Panelists was, “what can you say is needs to change to make cities work for all?
Jockin challenged the person who asked the question and also the audience: “ since 1976 when this discussion began in the 1st Habitat event in Vancouver, what have we all done since then to make what we discuss actualize in practice… we keep coming to these events, and we ask each other these questions and then we go away only to ask the same questions again.

Jockin On a networking Panel on Challenges of Sanitation:
In a networking event on sanitation, Jockin Challenges all the others in the panel and audience… “have you constructed even one toilet? In someone’s home, or a toilet shared by several families, or a community toilet in a slum?”
His perspective was that the actual DOING demonstrates the real challenges that stop universal sanitation from taking place.
Of all the MDGs that are critical fo rthe urban poor, this one is very tough because it’s the lack of practice, and learning and evolving solutions that has stagnated this development investment. Not money, not technology and policy.

Sunday, 1 April 2012

FROM SHEELA PATEL'S DIARY: MEETING OF GIZ AT ESCHBORN, APRIL 2012

At this event I was invited on behalf of SPARC and SDI to discuss the urban poor and cities. BMZ, which is the German department of development, which commissions GIZ and another agency to undertake the development investment is one of the few which is present in cities, and therefore it was of value for SDI and SPARC to showcase the value of citizen participation, especially as it pertains to informal slum dwellers.

My presentation at a side event  focused on the inability of cities to accommodate informality and the habitat and livelihood implications of these challenges to both slum dwellers and city. The global development agency also did not address the issue of urbanization with a perspective to embrace its challenges but rather to spread a sense of gloom about it
GIZ works with municipalities in Bangladesh and sitting next to a mayor who is a medical doctor and who works on a range of issues was interesting. Often meeting mayors at meetings like this is interesting, however there is rarely any follow-up. Also bilateral agencies do not seem to have any flexibility to explore additional possibilities.


Almuth Shauber of Miserioir and her colleagues were also present at the conference and gave us a chance to discuss organizational issues related to SPARC and Slum Dwellers International (SDI) .



In the final Plenary, all on the stage represented different constituency stakeholders and we challenged each other and the audience to embrace the urban challenge and to anticipate future possible scenarios by dealing with present deficits.
The constant discussion about participation never got actualized and the manipulation of projects to deliver what everyone but the poor considered important could be the cause of why many solutions were not sustainable.