Thursday, 26 July 2012

TALKING ABOUT TOILETS, JULY 2012

Jockin Arputam of Slum/Shack Dwellers International (SDI) and Jack Sims of World Toilet Organization (WTO) spend a day together in Mumbai 25th July 2012.
Both Jack Sims from World Toilet Organization (WTO) based in Singapore and working in many countries to improve sanitation and NSDF’s Jockin Arputam are passionate about sanitation and toilets and speak of “shit.”   Both come from similar humble backgrounds and a childhood of poverty. Jack focuses on improving the image of toilets and those who manage them through a wide range of activities and campaigns, while Jockin works on the access of the urban poor to sanitation, both as a means to strengthen citizenship entitlements of the poor in cities and as a way to engage the city with slum dwellers.

Jack Sims was last in Mumbai at a Dasra event earlier this year in which he and Sheela Patel of SPARC spoke about sanitation, he about bringing the discussion about defecation out of the closet, and she about the huge deficits in cities that make universal access to sanitation very difficult. They again met in Addis at the World Economic Forum meeting in Africa, and over many coffees and breakfasts began to explore the potential for exploring a closer working relationship. Clearly seeing a synergy in the values both Slum/Shack Dwellers International (SDI) and WTO bring to this issue internationally and also in India, where WTO is beginning to work on rural sanitation, The need for Jockin and Jack to meet and deepen this engagement seemed the next logical step.

The day began when Jack and two of his colleagues came to Dharavi to meet Jockin and NSDF and Mahila Milan representatives working on sanitation. Both shared stories of their journey that made them passionate about shit, shared their strategies, and discussed how they have made choices about what they do as advocacy, practical applications of what they preach, and where they seek to go.
Then women who have constructed toilets in Dharavi and Mahila Milan representatives who help organize communities took the three visitors to the community toilets being constructed and in different stages from beginning to post-construction. It was raining heavily as this is the monsoon period, but it did not deter the visit, and after the visit the whole group met again to reflect on questions from the visit and what to do moving forward.

Jack had a whole lot of questions, took copious notes, and raised many points for discussions. Clearly urban sanitation challenges were new to Jack and he was fascinated by issues of maintenance, financial models, designs of the toilets and what can be improved, the value of technology, and many other aspects.
Since he had a flight to catch, the meeting ended with a possible list of follow ups. Firstly, that Jack would initiate a write up about what he saw as potential to work together, which Jockin and Sheela would also work on.  Jack also got an agreement from Jockin to give ideas and suggestions to explore making the community sanitation process of construction design and delivery more efficient and both agreed that building community ownership of the facility and making it the center of the community was key to the challenge of sustained sanitation accesses.

TEXTILE PRODUCTION IN DHARAVI, JULY 2012

One man’s store sews denim belt loops onto jeans.  Five men sit in a room with sewing machines, the pants primed, flattened and ready to receive a belt-loop crown.  The owner lives in the room, works in the room, sews in the room.  And when the pants are looped and ready the bicycle driver arrives to pedal them to their next destination: the store where they will receive buttons.
One man’s store dyes leather.  A cowhide smell hangs alongside the pelts that are dyed to look teal, mustard, and petunia in color.  Next the leather might be fashioned into bags, pocketbooks, and belts but the shop-owner Tamma will never see the final product of his labors.  That said, Tamma will eat, sleep, and breathe leather; his home is his workshop is his life.
This hands-on production line model dominates Dharavi manufacture and makes it one of the world’s most efficient and integrated production chains.  Labor is hyper-specialized and workers have become artisans of the miniscule, excelling in the tiny arts of adding buttons onto collared shirts or sequins onto sari fabric. Hundreds of agents, contractors, and transport men link these independent laborers, thus eliminating the need for factory space or corporate affiliation.  Workers remain independent and minimize their land-use by fusing their home and workshop into one.  Space efficient, labor efficient, resource efficient—a most streamlined and specialized system of production.

TOILET BLOCKS AS WEAPONS FOR CORRUPTION , JULY 2012

A New York Times blog post published this Monday described a toilet block in Mumbai’s Cheeta Camp slum that perpetually passes through stages of building, demolition, and rebuilding to the rhythm of local elections.  Government candidates in poor urban areas often promise new toilet facilities to gain local support, and many candidates even begin construction on new toilet blocks before voting commences.  Once elected, though, candidates destroy the toilet blocks they began constructing.  The facilities disappear.  This cycle has endured in Cheeta Camp for over 15 years, long enough that residents of the slum no longer expect to see a new toilet block completed any time soon.

Yesterday members of SPARC visited one of SPARC’s most successful community toilet blocks near Crossroad Street in Dharavi.  This private toilet block serves over 1500 men, women, and children, who pay a 20 rupee monthly subscription fee for access to the facility.  Over its ten years of operation, the site has become one of the best maintained and most successful sanitation facilities that SPARC has built (it even has four functional English toilets available for handicap use!). During SPARC’s visit to the site yesterday, one community member spoke about a recent controversy: the local corporator is trying to take over the SPARC toilet block, even though it is owned and operated by a Community Based Organization (CBO).  The corporator is interested in this acquisition because the toilet block is so clean and lucrative that he thinks he can benefit from controlling it.

Building safe, clean, and affordable toilet blocks in slums can do much to improve sanitation conditions of the urban poor, yet toilet blocks are such vital and valuable centers of community life that they have become tantalizing targets for corrupt politicians. Knowing how imperative toilet blocks are to the well-being of their constituencies, some politicians will do anything they can to leverage toilet blocks for their own schemes even if it means taking away good sanitation facilities from the public.  This speaks to the power that clean toilet blocks have in communities, but it also dissuades community members from working to create safe sanitation facilities in their neighborhoods—why spend precious community resources on toilet block construction if the neighborhood will be dispossessed of these new toilet blocks later on?

Communities need a system of accountability, a way to register their facilities so that corrupt government officials cannot steal them away so easily.  Though no system of absolute accountability currently exists, relative accountability can be improved through community mapping: surveying neighborhoods and keeping accurate records of changes and developments in municipal corporation archives. After mapping is reported, existing laws can ensure that municipal corporations will respect the communal holdings on archive.  Another approach to accountability could be institutionalizing the toilet block construction and maintenance process, which involves a streamlined and uniform model of toilet block maintenance.  Communities can and should hold primary responsibility for their own toilet blocks, but to ensure that they stay within community control these facilities must come coupled with a commitment to sustained maintenance and mapping over-time.

Monday, 23 July 2012

MUMBAI NEEDS LAND AUDITING, JULY 2012

In his Hindustan Times article “The city needs a land audit,” Shalisesh Gaikwad references the Adarsh Housing Society Scam, a recent scandal in which Mumbai government officials constructed an apartment building for themselves on government land in Colaba under the guise of providing housing to retired personnel of Indian defense services.
In his article Gaikwad explains the controversy that has arisen between government officials who claim that the land they used for the new building in Colaba belongs to the state government and India’s Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) which calls the situation a “land grab” by the government.  In response to this debacle, Gaikwad notes other instances of fraud and corruption in recent Mumbai property dealings and he explains that the people of Mumbai should be concerned about the outcome of precedent-setting Adarsh since Mumbai’s egregious real-estate prices hang in the balance.  Gaikwad ends his article calling for an audit of public lands in Mumbai as a way to help formalize dealings of urban property and establish accurate records of land availability and ownership in the city.
Indeed Gaikwad is correct that the people of Mumbai should be concerned about the outcome of the Adarsh case, but the rationale for their concern should transcend simply curbing city real-estate prices. More importantly, the people of Mumbai should be concerned that dispossessing individuals of land for “public benefit” prolongs the cramped and unsanitary conditions of slums and informal housing sites and brings down the overall livability and economy of the city.
 A land audit is certainly a must, and it must include assessments of land ownership, plot size, vacant lots, and spaces that are “informally” occupied.  The past experience of the government’s Slum Rehabilitation Act (SRA) and Basic Services to the Urban Poor (BSUP) schemes has revealed that the identified lands that benefit the urban poor are often not correctly measured or the ownership of these lands is not defined. These omissions have not only lengthened the procedure for obtaining legal land clearances for relocation projects, but they have also resulted in forced evictions and fewer slum-dwellers able to stay in their homes because of inaccurate audit measurements.
The land audit to come should aim to produce a digitized database of survey findings in addition to standard paper records of the audit results.  When records only exist in paper they quickly become outdated and remain accessible only in institutions like municipal corporations, land revenue departments, and tax revenue departments.  These departments often do not coordinate with each other, meaning that obtaining accurate information on the state of land ownership can be nearly impossible.  This in turn jeopardizes projects that are meant to benefit the urban poor.
The hopeful land audit to come has the potential to provide easily-available, accurate, and updated land records for the public.  These records would be capable of serving myriad purposes: to identify ownership records, to locate vacant and available land for relocation and affordable housing projects, to feed into formulation of policies, schemes, and detailed project reports meant for the urban poor, among other benefits. Maintaining transparency in the audit process and the records that result from it will ensure fact-checked records for all concerned residents, civil society organizations, and the urban poor themselves.

A CALL FOR SUSTAINABLE SANITATION FACILITIES FOR THE URBAN POOR, JULY 2012

Over 50% of slums in urban India have no access to toilets.  Without the privacy and hygiene of proper toilet facilities, members of the urban poor risk their health and safety every time they relieve themselves. Those living on the pavements and in some slums need to resort to defecating out in the open, an undignified and uncomfortable activity which poses health dangers because of the waste left out in public space and safety concerns for women and children who expose themselves out in the open.  Women often wait until darkness to relieve themselves for privacy and safety reasons, another unhealthy and unpleasant consequence.  People who reside on the side of the railways often need to use the dangerous rail lines themselves as a toilet since no separate facility exists. This results in a steady stream of deaths each year as people are caught unaware while defecating and run over by speeding trains.

Khatrabai Londhe, a woman from Ghatkopar community in Mumbai, explained some of the safety problems that her community faced when they had no toilets available and had to result to open defecation:  “We use open land for defecating.  People passing by can see women squatting.  The day before yesterday an old women went out to defecate at seven in the evening and a man came from behind and grabbed her. . .  Men hide behind the bushes and watch women when they are squatting.  If they see a woman alone, they creep in and molest her.”

People should not need to engage in risky, humiliating, and potentially life-threatening behaviors in order to relieve themselves.  Because of this, the Indian government has demanded that government municipal corporations provide community toilets for public use, but unfortunately the government has not been able to grant toilet access to everyone in need.  Furthermore, the toilet blocks built by municipal corporations are often poorly designed, over-used, and unmaintained such that the facilities do not improve sanitation conditions very much.  Those who depend on municipal corporation toilets complain about the lack of cleanliness in the facility, the over-crowding of the space, and poor maintenance such that larvae often emerge from the toilet and crawl up their bare legs.

Access to a safe place to defecate is a basic human need.  Poor communities need alternatives to the methods of human waste disposal currently available to them, and they are capable of producing solutions to the problem if they can obtain the financial and organizational tools that will lead to collective mobilization and action.  Many solutions to the problem of defecation and sanitation exist, and with negotiation and collaboration within communities functional toilet blocks can be constructed and maintained.

SPARC's STRATEGY FOR COMMUNITY TOILET BLOCK CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE, JULY 2012

Due to the lack of availability of toilets in many communities and the dissatisfaction that communities feel towards toilets provided by municipal corporations, SPARC has launched its own community toilet block initiative in partnership with local communities.
SPARC believes that community toilet blocks are the best way to confront the issue of unsatisfactory sanitation conditions in slums.  SPARC advocates for community toilets rather than individual toilets because the size of most slum dwellings means that in-house toilets tend to dominate the interior space of the home, leaving less space for living and sleeping.  Furthermore, the smell of in-house toilets overwhelms homes and requires constant maintenance and attention.  Alternatively, community toilets allow for more space in individual homes and less overall time spent on cleaning and maintenance of the toilet facility.
Toilet block construction projects facilitated by SPARC differ from the toilet blocks built by government municipal corporations in many ways.  Whereas municipal corporations will build new toilet blocks without consulting communities, SPARC ‘s toilet blocks utilize community participation at every level—in design, construction, and maintenance.  SPARC toilet blocks are always connected to a main sewer line with access to adequate water and electricity even if that means building both overhead and underground tanks, whereas municipality toilet blocks do not always come with legal grid connections and extra capacity.  SPARC toilet blocks ensure privacy by including separate entrances and areas for men and women, and a separate squatting area for children.  SPARC toilet blocks also always come with a care-taker, appointed from the community who is responsible for the facility.  This is an improvement upon the municipal corporation model that does not consider maintenance of the toilet block to be a priority and does not account for maintenance practices in pricing or construction.  Last of all SPARC sells monthly subscriptions to the community toilet block where monthly family passes cost Rs. 20-25 irrespective of the number of family members or the number of toilet uses.  This system, coupled with an additional income of 1 rupee per use paid by passers-by, ensures that the toilet block remains financially accessible to all families while also funding its own operation.
SPARC sees community toilet blocks not only as a product that has the capacity to improve sanitation in slums, but also as a process in which toilet block design and construction can serve to rally community members to mobilize, organize, collaborate, and negotiate.
SPARC’s model of toilet block construction, subscription, and maintenance seems to deliver the desperately-needed clean and safe waste disposal facilities that families seek, which in turn improves health, productivity, safety and quality of life within urban communities.   SPARC has constructed 358 community toilet blocks to date and has also secured contracts to build another 613 toilet blocks moving forward. This means 371450 individuals in 74,290 families currently have access to safe and clean toilet facilities, and the number of people impacted by the projects continues to rise as new contracts are secured.  SPARC’s community-built toilets work because they are affordable and well –maintained and because families have a stake in their creation, use, and maintenance.
After a SPARC toilet block was constructed in her community, Sukubai Dengle from Kamgar Putala slum in Pune raved about the many improvements brought about by the new toilet block: “The two-storey toilet block has been built by SPARC and Mahila Milan. There is water in the toilets and no queues. There is no tension. And the toilets are so clean. I have a toilet in my house, but actually I like the new public toilets so much that I prefer to use them. Ever since the new toilets have been built, there is less sickness. The old toilets used to be so dirty that larvae used to come out of the chambers. The filth caused sickness. And children used to defecate in the open drains. Now there is such a good arrangement for children to squat that they go to the toilet happily. The new toilets have made a big difference in my settlement. I feel I live in a good area.”
Community toilet blocks are much more than structures or products; they are catalysts that enable community mobilization, coordination, empowerment, and improvement.  Proper sanitation in communities and safe and clean facilities for disposing of human waste have an impact that reaches beyond basic safety and health, instilling in poor communities a sense of ownership, commitment, and pride that will inspire further organization and growth.

RESPONDING TO URBAN SANITATION CHALLENGES AND MEETING GROWING DEMAND, JULY 2012

Throughout India over 3,000 dalits (untouchables) remove shit from public toilets every day, stinky excrement sloshing in barrels balanced atop their heads.  They come at night and remove the sloppy excrement from holes in the earth.  They load it into barrels and carry it far away to prevent public toilets from overflowing.
The necessity of dalits to manually remove and process human waste stems from India’s broken sanitation system, a system that frequently allows 8,000 people to share the same 40 toilets and that leaves over 50% of the poor with no options other than to defecate in open spaces. The uncontrollable quantity of human waste that all Indian cities deal with results from three major infrastructure problems: many cities lack sewage systems, those that have sewage systems do not extend their services to slums, and the ratio of people per toilet seat is so high that excrement does not have time to decompose before public toilets overflow with waste.
Unlike land, water, or electricity, which many poor people have found ways to obtain illegally, sanitation cannot be stolen from a nearby source.  There are no shortcuts. In order to be sustainable, sanitation requires collaborated and co-produced solutions with people, technology, and city governance structures all contributing their resources and ingenuity to the issue.
Despite immense need, the Indian people demonstrate deep abhorrence to addressing issues of defecation, its processing and treatment.  As a result the poor lack motivation to address problems of sanitation even though the health consequences that result from unsanitary conditions abound.  Why waste money constructing more toilet blocks if you face the possibility of eviction?  Why pay to defecate in filthy and stinky toilet facilities when you could just as easily go on the streets?
In sanitation surveys done by SPARC’s community groups, surveyors have found that slum-dwellers feel that they lack incentive to build up the infrastructure needed to bring sustained sanitation to their communities.  Thus, we believe that technical options need to expand exponentially to address these local challenges.  Technical solutions must be costed and also managed at the city level to help specific communities and households decide on the best sanitation method (individual household toilets, community toilets, water treatment, etc.) to meet their particular needs.  When sanitation comes coupled with the government’s promise that it will endure in communities regardless of slum rehabilitation schemes, the poor will likely be more receptive to exploring long-term solutions.
Additionally women must be involved in new sanitation initiatives in order to make sanitation projects sustainable, since women understand their community’s style and needs and also they can educate by example and teach the next generation about proper sanitation practices and behaviors.  In the past women have been left out of discussions of sanitation improvements in slums, but they will be the key implementers of behavior changes that come with better sanitation and they deserve to participate in sanitation projects as they arise.
If implemented properly, sanitation can become a sustained basis for community engagement with city and neighborhood authorities.  Proper sanitation facilities will lead to slums safe from disease and infestation, and they will also grow to inspire better tariffs, garbage collection, health education, and safety in partnership with government authorities moving forward.