Thursday, 10 January 2013

MILAN NAGAR: MAHILA MILAN INITIATES DESIGN CONCEPTS, JANUARY 2013

From 1990 onwards, Byculla Mahila Milan attended exchanges in India and internationally to share their experience of getting organized, of learning to use their own experience to design a core house for themselves, and of planning a settlement design from it.

Initially, women used boxes and cardboard to develop ideas to visually communicate with each other.  This allowed them to question the practicality of ideas and explore ways to keep experimenting.

The community as a whole usually joined in to air their reflections and often groups would compete to find the best concepts. Nothing was right or wrong, the focus was on what was needed, affordable, and doable.Ultimately, the houses resembled the kuccha houses in which the pavement dwellers lived in.  The vertical design allows the households to accommodate more members and have more space.
                              

MILAN NAGAR THE STORY BEGINS.....JANUARY 2013

The picture on top is of Dimtimkar Road and the one on the bottom is of Sophia Zubair Road. Both these streets have families predominantly from Bihar who came to Mumbai seeking work in textile and weaving, but had to abandon their skill as weavers of fine tussar silk and become scrap collectors.
The women of these communities are amongst the oldest group of women’s collectives engaged in the housing program developed by the Mahila Milan and SPARC.  These Byculla communities were the first group to be relocated to Mankurd since they were both prepared and considered a priority of the city municipality.


In order to set the ground work for the relocation, the alliance was seeking to bring closure to the pavement dwellers rehabilitation policy by supporting the MAHATMA GANDHI PADAPATH YOJANA.  The yojana was announced by the state government in order to improve the road access for smooth running of vehicles by identifying pavement dwellers as persons needing relocation. The committee from Milan Nagar popularized the relocation by putting up a poster stating “ WE ARE MOVING FROM DARKNESS TO LIGHT”. 

All of the neighborhood ward officials of the corporation, the local police station and the buildings whose walls the pavement dwellers huts were built on were informed that the obligation to keep the pavements clear was now theirs.

Milan Nagar, a cooperative society of  pavement dwellers, consisting of 536 households was formed in 1986 as a spearhead movement of pavement dwellers seeking to get secure housing away from the pavements. In 1986 they developed a design and a strategy for housing, began to save money, seek land, and also build skills and confidence of other pavement and slum dwellers to encourage them of the path they were exploring. Between 1991 to 2000 there were numerous  policies and projects which led to others in Mumbai and other slum dwellers in Indian, Asia, and Africa to secure tenure and housing options through this federating process. In 2000, Mahila Milan registered a piece of land in Mankurd to Milan Nagar. After overcoming many problems and challenges, in 2005 80 households moved to Mankurd.

Friday, 21 December 2012

COMMUNITY PROFESSOR KATANA EXPLAINING THE SDI RITUALS, DECEMBER 2012

Peter Kassaija, the enthusiastic teacher spearheading the partnership at Makerere stated “ We want students to go beyond sitting in the office and into the field in order to get to know the communities which they plan for. For the federation members the lines of communication are now open and they [the students] will learn as much from you as you will from them.” This is a welcome attitude and one from which many academic institutions can learn. Practical field experience of informal settlements not only debunks myths but exposes students to conditions and people who are normally excluded or given mere “lip service” in planning decisions about their own areas. During this process students will be forced to engage beyond the confines of the classroom with forms of knowledge that are not included in their curriculum's but which are absolutely vital to the future equitable development of cities.
It is these types of partnerships that have the potential to not only create new spaces for learning but also enable informal community knowledge to become part of citywide slum upgrading processes. Across the SDI network tireless federation members are working to ensure that the knowledge of community professors is taken seriously and incorporated in developmental frameworks. If we are truly to change the segregated spatial form and exclusionary policies of future cities it is time that we all sat up and took very seriously the lessons which community professors can teach us. As Katana aptly sums up, “ An old broom sweeps better than a new broom. That is community members they have experience of all the corners and the problems in their communities.”

Tuesday, 11 December 2012

SANITATION INTERVENTION IN SMALL TOWNS OF MAHARASHTRA, DECEMBER 2012

Based on slum profiles conducted by Mahila Milan and Federation, more than 50% of the total population remains unserved with toilets. Therefore a proposal was submitted to construct a new toilet in Saint Mary Church (Ahmednagar), Anna Bhau Sathe, Wadala (Nasik) and Numani Nagar (Malegaon) along with repairs of two existing toilet blocks in  Anna Bhau Sathe (Ahmednagar) and Amprapali (Nasik) and grant funds to make this happen were finalized.  Then the federations informed us about recent events in their city ….

In Ahmednagar: the original plan was to construct a new toilet at Saint Mary and repair the toilet in Anna Bhau Sathe.  Over the last couple of months, the Mahila Milan leaders at Ahmednagar had been in conversation with the local Municipal representative and  municipal authorities. These discussions have borne fruit and the Municipality has begun the construction of toilets at Saint Mary Church!

In Nasik: the original plan was to construct a new toilet at Anna Bhau Sathe, Wadala and repairing
Amrapali toilet. Because Anna Bhau Sathe slum is on a private land, a toilet cannot be constructed on it.

In Malegaon: the original plan was to construct a new toilet in Numani Nagar, however the new elected local municipal representatives, have taken up the work of meeting the toilet needs in Numani Nagar and other settlements.

Clearly we see this as a feature of communities feeling empowered to have discussions once they have some funds in their pockets. It triggers a response from politicians and administration who then want to supply them with what they are entitled to so.

Since assured grant exist for these cities, federation members now suggest the following:

Nasik - Repairs of existing toilets in Amrapali slums
Ahmednagar - Repairs of existing toilets and constructing new toilets at Anna Bhau Sathe slum and Munjuba Chowk
Malegaon -Individual toilet loans in different settlements

Setting precedents where community collective pursuit of entitlements begins with the Mahila Milan taking initiatives is critical. When modest funds are made available, their visit to city administrations seeking permission often induces the city to provide the facility because most often they have the money but it is not their priority to utilize it. This also invokes a sense of pride ownership and begins to set an example to others about also mimicking this action, only now someone else has shown the way and can accompany them to get the next and the next facility.







Monday, 10 December 2012

A REPORT ON ODISHA BY SUNDAR BURRA, DECEMBER 2012

Sundar Burra was invited by Shri I.Srinivas, IAS, Principal Secretary, Housing and Urban Development Department, Government of Odisha (GOO), to speak at a capacity building workshop for Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). The workshop was held in Bhubaneswar on Saturday, December 8, 2012 and it opened with a prize giving ceremony in which the Chief Minister gave awards to various ULBs. Altogether there were 103 ULBs represented with only a few municipal corporation and municipalities. The vast majority of ULBs were Notified Area Committees (NACs) with low levels of population. Each ULB was represented by usually two elected persons and one official. About 400 people attended the function.

Ms. Madhu Kishwar of Centre for Study of Developing Societies (CSDS), New Delhi, spoke about urban street vendors and the laws, polices and programmes concerning these groups. There were two speakers from WIPRO and TCS who made brief presentations on E-Governance. Sundar Burra and Monalisa Mohanty from SPARC spoke about the problems faced in slum upgradation, slum resettlement and slum redevelopment under various different government programmes like the Basic Services for Urban Poor (BSUP) in different States. SPARC emphasized the role of community participation at all stages of the process including the preparation of detailed project reports (DPRs).

The Principal Secretary Shri Srinivas, though he had joined only a few months ago, has introduced a path-breaking  legislation in the Assembly for the Rights of the Urban Poor to live in cities. It is expected that this bill will become law during the current session of the Assembly. Shri Srinivas is an excellent officer whose heart is in the right place. He accompanied Monalisa Mohanty and Sunder to a slum on the day before the workshop and interacted with the Mahila Milan women from different cities in Odisha. Both from the point of view of the project on urban poverty that PRIA and SPARC are doing together and also from a more general perspective, it is important for us to engage with  Shri Srinivas and showcase his efforts in Odisha to a national audience. How to do this can be the subject of discussion. It was deeply heartening to observe his commitment.

Monday, 5 November 2012

TALKING ABOUT TOILETS WITH AVIK ROY, NOVEMBER 2012

In August 2012, Jack Sims of WTO (World Toilet Organization) together with Avik Roy and three others examined toilets designed, constructed and managed by communities in Mumbai with the assistance of the Alliance. The object of their visit was to explore the possibility of developing a financial sustainable strategy for the management and maintenance of toilets built in slums. 

After concluding a week long meeting with the MM and the NSDF leaders managing the sanitation projects, Avik met with the members of SPARC. Avik heads an organization called Base of the Pyramid (BOP) that works with numerous development organizations. He assisted Jeb Brugman and C.K. Prahalad with their work in actualizing the practice lin
ked to working with the bottom of the pyramid. The discussion between Avik and SPARC was to both to receive feedback from the team as well as to help the team understand the Alliance's conditions, concerns, and strategies to further improve the functions of the toilet blocks.


What SPARC said:
Main concerns:
Since partnerships are required to be sustained over an extended period of time, the first phase should evaluate the values, assumptions, and capacities of each organization to handle each other’s functioning. These projects are successful if soft money and grants blend with hard money in an attempt to develop a market savvy strategy needed to acknowledge this blend. Eventually, the obvious and evident aspects will pale in comparison to the issues, challenges, and problems which both the organizations will have to jointly face.
About working with communities:
Although SPARC is a vital partner, this process has to include the leaders of MM and NSDF who will be managing the sanitation program. Any suggestions will be accepted if, through trial and error, it demonstrates an increase in the community's’ collective empowerment.
About the concept of SPA:
The concept of reformulating toilet as a SPA seems disconnected with the Indian concept.  In turn, we need to look at an Indian name which people can relate to.
About working in different wards in Mumbai:
WTO should look at locations from a ward wise perspective.  SPARC can select a ward and develop demo projects which can be scaled up at the ward level.
About working in smaller towns:
The slums of Mumbai are consolidated, thus working in Mumbai is equivalent to working in a “retrofitting” context.  Consideration should be given to working in smaller towns where the slums are not so dense and also to working at city scale.
Working on sanitation:
Sanitation should be seen as an issue to provide universal sanitation; as providing safe and dignified provisions where other amenities and services make the facility a community hub that is attractive and pulls in participation.

What they said:
Avik and his team agreed upon concerns raised by SPARC and committed that this project will be a pilot project and will be treated patiently. He is also trying to bring the private actors in this process to make it financially viable. 
Further his team is also thinking of changing the concept name from community SPA to a name which appeals to slum communities.












Friday, 2 November 2012

DHARAVI NEWS: SECTOR 5 INAUGURATION GETS DISRUPTED, NOVEMBER 2012

Dharavi redevelopment project is continuing to remain in flux. Somehow, the recommendations and suggestions made by the Committee of Experts is never actually explored in the spirit of the advise.
The recommendation not to take all five sectors together, but  only start with sector 4 was initially suggested. Sector 4 is a dense sector where the communities have themselves begun to work on exploring solutions. Instead the state and MHADA chose sector five which does not produce robust solutions for the rest of Dharavi.
Another recommendation made after sector five was selected was to develop a master plan for Dharavi and then work through NGOs with the community. Unfortunately, without implementing any of the recommendations, an inauguration ceremony was initiated and after eight years  the people are once again resisting the intervention.
“Why are the benefits of capitalization of land not being shared with the people of Dharavi?”